Working With ‘Big 5’ Firms Vs. Midsize Tech Partners: Pros And Cons
CEO at Sphere.
As the CEO and founder of an IT services company for the last 19 years, I have witnessed a transformation in technology consulting: Many companies are moving away from major consulting firms’ traditional, one-size-fits-all approaches. In fact, amid recent economic uncertainty, many companies are completely rethinking their approach (paywall) to working with consultants.
Companies will need to consider many factors when making their decision about which consulting firm to choose, so let’s examine the pros and cons of working with the “Big 5” IT consulting firms versus midsize tech partners.
Partnering With The ‘Big 5’
Working with the “Big 5” IT consulting firms is often a choice driven by their brand reputation and unmatched resources. Yet, limited adaptability can hinder their effectiveness. When making your decision, here are a few of the pros to consider:
1. Brand Reputation: The brand reputation of Big 5 IT consulting firms instills confidence in clients and stakeholders. As the commonly used expression goes, “No one ever got fired for hiring McKinsey.” The established brand credibility enhances trust in the quality and reliability of the services provided.
2. Extensive Resources: The “Big Four” IT consulting companies (Deloitte, PwC, KPMG and EY) collectively hold 37.4% of the global consultancy market, followed by Accenture, which captures 5.5%. These companies have a broad network of experts, tech infrastructure, research and development capabilities, and significant financial backing. With these resources, they can tackle large-scale projects.
3. Global Reach: The biggest IT consulting firms operate in multiple countries and regions. The “Big Four” claim roughly 35% of the global management consulting market, while the “MBB” trio (McKinsey, BCG and Bain) represent about 10%. This global presence enables them to offer localized support and services for different markets’ specific needs and regulations.
That said, there are a few potential drawbacks that you will want to keep in mind:
1. Inflexibility: Large IT consulting firms typically rely on rigid structures with steep retainers and long-term engagements, which may not meet the needs of companies seeking flexible and on-demand services. Their size often leads to complex decision-making processes, hindering agility in project execution. The extensive hierarchy may delay client needs responses, impacting project timelines and outcomes.
2. Lack Of Specialized Expertise: Last year, University College London economist Mariana Mazzucato raised concerns about major IT consulting firms, noting a lack of specialized expertise in key areas of advice. It raises doubts about the effectiveness and credibility of their services, pointing out potential knowledge gaps and shortcomings of their advice to clients.
3. Conflicts Of Interest, Poor Culture And Lack Of Transparency: There are several significant concerns regarding the tendency of big consulting firms toward conflicts of interest, lack of transparency and unethical behavior, according to Jane Andrew, professor of accounting at the University of Sydney Business School. Among other things, Andrew points out that these firms have been accused of prioritizing profit over public interest, submitting inflated invoices, providing inadequate reports and advising clients on how to avoid legal regulations.
Working With Midsize Tech Partners
Gartner defines midsize companies as organizations with 100 to 999 employees. Transitioning to midsize tech partners can provide corporations with speed, agility, specialized expertise and access to innovative technologies, but these firms may not have the resources of the Big 5.
Here are some of the upsides of choosing a midsize partner:
1. Agility In Adaptation: According to the Harvard Business Review, midsize companies are more adaptable to changing demands as they are smaller and less encumbered by bureaucracy. With their lean structures, proactive engagement and iterative development, midsize tech partners can meet client-specific needs efficiently.
2. Specialized Expertise For Innovative Custom Solutions: Midsize companies foster innovation by creating safe spaces for employee experimentation, investing in diverse teams and allocating dedicated time for innovation activities. Midsize specialized tech partners also have in-house experts to offer bespoke solutions to clients’ unique challenges.
3. Cutting-Edge Technologies And Tools: According to McKinsey, small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) contribute to approximately half of the overall $370 billion spent on technology, outspending the large enterprise accounts in the telecom and electronic devices sectors. Investments allow midsize tech partners to keep on top of technological advancements. Moreover, their experts have more freedom to implement innovative technologies and tools. As a result, midsize IT companies can be more agile, adaptive and adept at integrating the latest innovations, such as AI and IoT, ensuring competitiveness and relevance.
With those benefits in mind, here are a few challenges you might face when working with midsize tech partners:
1. Reliability And Stability Concerns: The reliability and stability of midsize tech partners, particularly in contrast to well-established corporations, may raise apprehension. It can manifest as doubts about their ability to deliver consistent results and maintain service uptime. Choosing a midsize tech company that has demonstrated its long-term viability, abundant resources and technical expertise to engage effectively with large enterprises can help to alleviate this concern.
2. Limited Resources: Midsize tech partners typically have fewer resources compared to giant corporations, which can lead to limitations in funding, workforce and tech capabilities. While they can often provide more focus and provide clients with personalized attention, they may not have the same reach as the Big 5.
3. Lack Of Scalability: Some corporations may fear that midsize tech partners will struggle to scale their solutions and services. Choosing a midsize tech partner with long-term viability can help to accommodate dynamic industry requirements and ensure adaptability to fluctuating demands.
Choosing Impact: Big 5 Vs. Midsize Tech Partners
While opting for “Big Five” can often be playing it safe, decision-makers at industry-leading companies should prioritize partners that deliver tangible outcomes, which may mean the agility, specialized expertise and access to technological innovations of a midsize firm. In the end, the ultimate choice between the “Big 5” and midsize tech partners depends on how well they align with your organization’s priorities.
Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?
link